If you think you have an above-average sense of taste, you are very wrong. Most people have no real sense of what combinations of flavours will appeal to them.
It is because our sense of taste is based almost entirely on what our taste buds learn from eating.
And, since we only eat about 200 different foods and beverages throughout our entire lifetime, we know from a tiny fraction of the millions of possibilities available to us.
Trying to please everyone all the time will leave you feeling drained and empty. And you will constantly be wondering if anyone likes you or not.
In this article, I’m going to reveal ten incredibly unique and bizarre flavour combinations.
In this Article
Fun & Weird Coffee Creamer Flavors
Coffee-Mate Nestle Chocolate Chip Cookie Creamer
Coffee-Mate’s Nestle Chocolate Chip Cookie creamer tastes just like chocolate chip cookie dough, but it’s even better because it uses real Nestle chocolate chips instead of just cocoa powder.
It doesn't taste exactly like eating raw cookie dough, but you can tell it has chocolate chips in it. And you can even see brown flecks of the actual chip in the Coffee-Mate liquid.
It’s one of the best coffee creamer flavours I’ve ever tasted. And I’m sure most people would agree with me.
Coffee-Mate Girl Scouts Thin Mints Creamer
The Coffee-Mate Girl Scouts Thin Mints flavour is an obvious choice for people who like Girl Scout Cookies. But you’ll probably want to add something like sugar-free vanilla or hazelnut syrup to make it taste even better.
A cool thing about Coffee-Mate creamer is that they also offer a wide range of flavours based on things like Girl Scout Cookies, Hershey's Chocolate, and even Oreos. So it's perfect for people who like to keep an old fashioned cup-of-joe in their kitchen.
Coffee-Mate Girl Scouts Caramel & Coconut Creamer
The Coffee-Mate Girl Scouts Caramel & Coconut flavour is an entirely new flavour perfect for people who like to drink their hot beverages with a spoon.
It's delicious and contains real caramel bits instead of just vanilla or chocolate. The coconut flavour is very light, but you can still tell it's there. And the caramel adds an extra level of sweetness that pretty much everyone will enjoy.
Coffee-Mate Mexican Chocolate Creamer
The Coffee-Mate Mexican Chocolate Creamer is a somewhat strange combination of coffee creamer flavours. But it’s not so weird that most people would dislike it.
When you drink coffee with this Mexican chocolate creamer, you get a nice kick of ancho chilli pepper flavour and a hint of cinnamon and nutmeg spice.
Some people may not be too crazy about the Mexican chocolate taste, but if you like cinnamon and spicy foods, you might love this Coffee-Mate flavour.
Coffee-Mate Dulce de Leche Creamer
The Coffee-Mate Dulce de Leche creamer is the best thing you can put in your hot beverage if you love caramel.
This coffee creamer contains authentic dulce de leche, and it tastes just like caramel sauce on top of milk chocolate ice cream.
It’s creamy and smooth, and it has a great texture to it. There are even flecks of what looks like chocolate chips floating around in there.
Coffee-Mate Eggnog Creamer
Coffee-Mate’s Eggnog flavour is perfect for people who like to drink their hot beverages with a bit of sugar and spice.
This Coffee-Mate flavour has a vital essence of nutmeg and cinnamon, making it taste like something your grandmother would make for you on Christmas eve.
And the cream texture is just right. It’s not too heavy, but it’s still thick enough to feel creamy and smooth as you drink it down.
Coffee-Mate Gingerbread Creamer
The Coffee-Mate Gingerbread flavour is delicious, but it’s not for people who like anything even resembling “gingerbread.” This Coffee-Mate creamer tastes almost identical to gingerbread cookies with icing on them.
The cream texture isn't exactly the right texture, but it's close enough that you can still enjoy it. Some people even prefer the surface of this coffee creamer over what would be considered normal.
Coffee-Mate Espresso Chocolate (Star Wars Limited Edition)
The Coffee-Mate Espresso Chocolate flavour is not for coffee fans. It’s more of an “extra thick hot chocolate” kind of creamer that gives all the richness and sweetness you could ever want in a hot drink. And it has swirls of chocolate syrup floating around in there.
So if you like chocolate, there is nothing better than this Coffee-Mate creamer.
Chobani Sweet Cream Dairy Coffee Creamer
The Chobani Sweet Cream Dairy Coffee creamer is the best thing of all time. No question about it. If you have ever had a latte at Starbucks, you have already tasted this Coffee-Mate creamer flavour.
It tastes just like sweet cream yoghurt with a splash of coffee mixed in. So if you are not a Starbucks fan who doesn't want to go there anymore, this is for you. It's delicious, fresh, and natural!
Briar Homemade Peanut Butter Cup Coffee Creamer
The Briar Homemade Peanut Butter Cup Coffee Creamer is probably one of the strangest Coffee-Mate flavours that you will ever try.
It has natural peanut butter, and it tastes just like a peanut butter cup with a Starbucks caramel coffee blend poured over the top.
You can tell that this is a unique Coffee-Mate flavour because this creamer’s peanut butter taste is robust. Some people have described it as tasting just like a peanut butter cup with a cinnamon twist. That’s what it is!
Almond milk-based caramel coffee creamer
I found this recipe for making your Coffee-Mate-style creamer in a blog called “Frugal and Sustainable.”
The blogger created her version of the Coffee-Mate Dulce de Leche creamer, and I think it came out great! She recommends using hazelnut syrup in the recipe because it adds a lot of flavours.
But I decided to use coconut nectar instead because I wanted to get a more natural taste. I think the recipe turned out well, and I’m sure you could try using vanilla extract instead of caramel extract if you don’t like the idea of all the artificial ingredients in there.
This coffee creamer is excellent, and I can't wait to try new flavours with it!
Baileys Coffee Creamer
The Baileys Coffee Creamer is perfect for people who like to get their morning coffee on the rocks. Or, in this case, on the ice cream.
The texture is nice and creamy, and it has a strong taste of coffee flavour. But the Baileys flavour isn't so strong that it overpowers everything you try to mix it with. You can easily add it to hot chocolate or pour some into a glass of ice-cold milk.
Coffee-Mate White Chocolate Mocha Decadence
The Coffee-Mate White chocolate Mocha Decadence is a simple white chocolate coffee creamer that adds a little extra sweetness to your beverage. It’s incredibly unique, and you can easily add a spoonful of it to your hot concoctions.
You can also mix it with cold coffee or even cold almond milk if you feel like it. It's not too sweet, but it is very creamy and smooth.
DELICIOUS HOMEMADE COFFEE CREAMER RECIPES
Coffee creamer is a must in every kitchen, and the best thing about the recipes listed below is how easy they all are to make.
They are simple, cheap and dairy-free, but best of all, they taste amazing. And no matter which recipe you choose to make, I promise that you will enjoy it.
ALMOND JOY COFFEE CREAMER
Nutty, rich, and creamy… this is the perfect coffee creamer for every morning. This recipe works perfectly with both French roasted and dark roast coffee.
PUMPKIN SPICE COFFEE CREAMER
The best thing about this creamer is that you can make it for your next fall party ahead of time. It’s perfect for Thanksgiving and Halloween, maybe even Christmas! After straining the creamer mixture, you can also use this recipe to make a homemade vanilla syrup with the leftover pulp.
MOCHA COCONUT HOMEMADE CREAMER
This Mocha-Flavored Creamer works perfectly with both flavoured and unflavored coffee. The coconut flavour works well with the chocolate syrup, and the black coffee perfectly compliments it.
SIMPLE COCONUT MILK CREAMER
This Coconut Creamer is perfect for when you are in the mood for something unique. It tastes great on any coffee, so feel free to have it with an Americano or a Flat White. It’s also great on hot cocoa, dairy-free ice cream, or even plain yoghurt.
CHOCOLATE CHIP COCONUT CHAI HOMEMADE CREAMER
Chai uses ground spices, which are already in the five simple ingredients, making this creamer extremely easy to make at home. You can also use chocolate chip cookies or vegan chocolate chips to get that extra bit of flavour.
VANILLA ALMOND MILK COFFEE CREAMER
This creamer contains only six simple ingredients, including vanilla extract. The almond milk gives it a little extra sweetness, and it’s even better than Chobani’s.
ROASTED ALMOND HOMEMADE COFFEE CREAMER
This creamer has only five ingredients, including almond butter. It is delicious on any coffee or tea, and you can even use it in place of vanilla ice cream in chocolate chip cookie dough bars!
CINNAMON APPLE CIDER HOMEMADE COFFEE CREAMER
This recipe only has five ingredients, and it’s perfectly spiced for the fall season. It works best on coffee or tea, but you can also try it with a slice of pumpkin bread.
COCONUT HOMEMADE COFFEE CREAMER
This Coffee Creamer is exceptionally creamy and has a perfect coconut coffee flavour. You can use it as a delicious creamer or flavour your milk for protein shakes.
Whacky Coffee Flavors You Have To Try Once
You might not normally drink coffee, but you can make it taste like anything with these recipes.
Black Velvet Cognac Coffee
The Black Velvet Cognac Coffee is perfect for people who like to get their morning coffee on the rocks. Or, in this case, on the ice cream! The texture is nice and creamy, and it has a strong taste of cognac flavour, but it isn’t so strong that you can’t mix it with hot chocolate or milk.
Mocha Cream Soda
This Mocha Cream Soda tastes just like an old-fashioned cream soda. It’s perfect for Halloween and is sure to be a hit!
Coffee-Mate Black Cherry Hot Chocolate
You can make this recipe with any flavoured coffee, and it will still taste great. And you can use any hot chocolate mix instead of the Hot Cocoa Mix. Then, mix everything in a blender, and you’ll have a drink for the whole family.
Coffee-Mate High Protein Hot Chocolate
This Hot Chocolate Flavor is very rich and creamy. You can pair it with any hot chocolate mix or use skim milk if you have any flavoured coffee. Either way, this drink is the best!
Peanut Butter Coffee Creamer
If you want to have some peanut butter in your morning cup of coffee, this recipe will satisfy your cravings. This creamer is perfect for people who are allergic or sensitive to dairy products.
Coffee-Mate Banana Cream Hot Chocolate
Some people have a hard time making the perfect cup of hot chocolate, but this recipe solves that problem.
You can use any coffee, and it will still taste great. Then, add 2 or 3 tablespoons to your favourite hot chocolate mix or add plenty of banana-flavoured syrup and serve it with ice cream for a delicious banana split.
Making homemade coffee creamer can be very easy. First, you need to follow the recipe, and you will soon experience the creamy deliciousness of your homemade coffee creamer.
This drink is often compared to store-bought varieties, but it is far better than most expensive alternatives.